[{"caption":"Types of carport roofing material?","columns":[{"key":"construction","label":"What the choice describes","source_line":"Material, roof-form and parking-layout descriptions: source links and read dates accompany each row."},{"key":"scope","label":"What the proposal should resolve","source_line":"Model and planning figures apply only to the named source and stated basis."}],"rows":[{"option":"steel","label":"Steel frame","cells":{"construction":{"text":"Steel identifies the frame material. ShelterLogic’s Arrow and STEELPEAK comparison specifies 29-gauge roof panels; the frame name alone does not identify the roof shape.","facts":["steel-type","panel-gauge"]},"scope":{"text":"Name the model, roof-load figure and anchor details. Arrow Storage lists 35 PSF; STEELPEAK lists 40 PSF. These are model figures, not a site-load determination.","facts":["arrow-snow","peak-snow"]}}},{"option":"aluminum","label":"Aluminum frame / polycarbonate roof","cells":{"construction":{"text":"Canopia combines an aluminum frame with polycarbonate roof panels; the roof and frame are different materials.","facts":["frame-roof"]},"scope":{"text":"Canopia describes aluminum as rust-resistant; its roof panels are polycarbonate.","facts":["frame-roof","aluminum-rust"]}}},{"option":"wood","label":"Wood frame","cells":{"construction":{"text":"Historic examples include wood or metal frames, attached lean-to covers and freestanding covers. Attachment is a separate choice from the frame material.","facts":["wood-metal","attachment","freestanding"]},"scope":{"text":"HUD’s undated multifamily planning table lists wood-frame carports at 30 years, versus 40 for metal frames. These are capital-needs estimates, not individual service-life predictions.","facts":["a2-wood-life","metal-life"]}}},{"option":"solar","label":"Solar roof","cells":{"construction":{"text":"Solar describes electricity-producing roofing, which can be combined with a separately specified supporting frame.","facts":["solar-function","solar-type"]},"scope":{"text":"DOE describes building-integrated solar materials replacing conventional building materials. Specify the electricity-producing covering and the supporting frame separately.","facts":["solar-function","solar-type"]}}},{"option":"portable","label":"Fabric-covered steel frame","cells":{"construction":{"text":"ShelterLogic describes a fabric-covered steel structure for temporary or semi-permanent use. Fabric describes the covering, rather than a replacement for the frame.","facts":["a2-fabric-type"]},"scope":{"text":"The maker says these structures should always be anchored.","facts":["a2-fabric-type","a2-fabric-anchoring"]}}}]},{"caption":"What is the best metal carport?","columns":[{"key":"evidence","label":"Published figure and its limits","source_line":"ShelterLogic model comparison and HUD undated multifamily planning table; read 2026-11-09."}],"rows":[{"option":"steel","label":"Arrow Storage model figures","cells":{"evidence":{"text":"35 PSF snow load; 100 MPH wind rating; 29-gauge roof panels. The comparison does not state the wind test standard.","facts":["arrow-snow","arrow-wind","panel-gauge"]}}},{"option":"steel","label":"STEELPEAK model figures","cells":{"evidence":{"text":"40 PSF snow load; 115 MPH wind rating; 29-gauge roof panels. Request the model drawings and site design basis.","facts":["peak-snow","peak-wind","panel-gauge"]}}},{"option":"aluminum","label":"Metal-frame asset planning","cells":{"evidence":{"text":"40 years: HUD planning estimate for multifamily housing, row 3.2.4.11 Carports, metal frame, in both family and elderly columns. The row does not split steel from aluminum.","facts":["metal-life"]}}},{"option":"wood","label":"Wood-frame asset planning","cells":{"evidence":{"text":"30 years in both family and elderly columns: HUD’s undated multifamily planning estimate, row 3.2.4.10 Carports, wood frame. Roof-form and solar-equipment life are separate.","facts":["a2-wood-life"]}}}]}]